As Summer closes, it would be a missed opportunity as a chubby Toms River resident not to highlight my 5 favorite ice cream shops in Toms River. Honestly, there are more than 5 great places in Toms River and dozens more all over the Jersey Shore. However, I want to spotlight the ones I and my family hit on an all too regular basis.
Criteria For My Favorite Ice Cream Shops In Toms River Is Simple
I have very specific ice cream flavors and textures I go with. Normally I’m pretty daring with my food. For example, I usually will go to a Japanese restaurant, or Asian Fusion joint, and order a sushi roll or cooked dish that I have never had before. Moreover, if there is an opportunity to go spicy, I’ll usually take it, sometimes to my detriment. Yet when it comes to ice cream I play it close to the vest. If we are talking soft serve, I’m a vanilla man through and through. Once in a while, I get a taste for the chocolate or orange cream twist, but for the most part, it’s soft-serve vanilla in a cup or sugar cone, not a waffle cone guy.
As for hard ice cream, which is the majority of my family’s ice cream adventure, I stray far from my wife and both my kids. They all LOVE chocolate chip mint, or mint chocolate chip, or whatever the hell that evil green spearmint concoction is. I loathe it! My teenage son will also go for the wackiest sugar-laden offering in the shop. We’re talking about your cotton candy, birthday cake, and cookie monster collection. My daughter is a fixins fan. No matter what she gets, it always has to have something on the top or the bottom. My wife usually does the “surprise me” answer if I’m going on a run. She knows I know, she’s a chocoholic of the highest degree.
RELATED: Comfort Food Festival Returns To Downtown Toms River
So the surprise always involves chocolate somewhere. Me? Nope, hard ice cream is a narrow road for me. I like vanilla peanut butter. I like butter crunch, or butter brickle. Don’t hate! I have a little love for pistachio, but not enough to put it into a regular rotation. Same with coffee ice cream. There is one homemade combo flavor, however, that they make at one of the shops on this list that is my current favorite. So with that, here are my 5 favorite ice cream shops in Toms River. What are yours?
Speaking of Toms River, check out this story on the upcoming Downtown Toms River Comfort Food Fest!
