New Jersey’s Favorite Cheesesteak Places And One Place Is The Clear Winner! New Jersey is loaded with places that make some darn good cheesesteak sandwiches. I asked hundreds of folks where they go in the state of New Jersey to get their favorite cheesesteaks. It really is hard to say who has the best cheesesteaks because it’s subjective.
Some of us like onions, peppers, and plastic liquid cheese. Some of us like just the meat or chicken and a few slices of melted Cooper Sharp.
People like me LOVE provolone somewhere in the mix, and so on and so on. Some of my favorites are on the list, and there’s ONE place in South Jersey that people go wild over.
Lillo’s Tomato Pies
I have plans on heading down their soon to finally sink my teeth into the one of their famous cheesesteaks because THIS place got a ton of mentions, and I mean a ton. How can I not get in the car and go?
I had to remove a few places that are sadly, no longer in business, or fell off the list due to changes in the ingredients since this past Spring.
Take a look at this updated list of places that made the cut. (Updated February 2024)
Big Blue Wrap & Roll Food Truck Check out their website to see where they'll pop up next
Another great food truck makes it on to the list. Lorraine Delizia and her husband Michael own a great business called “Butter Me Up”, they make a gourmet compound butter and fabulous scones, and this is Lorraine’s favorite cheesesteak.
Monmouth Clubhouse Deli - 825 W Park Ave, Ocean Township, NJ 07712
Located in the Cobblestone Village Shopping Center. My friend Robin Thompson loves the sandwiches here. Dell, one of our listeners suggested I add the Clubhouse Deli to the list of places selling juicy, flavorful cheesesteaks. He likes his cheesesteak on a roll with lots of onions and mushrooms. I used to live around the corner and I love the grilled chicken panini and the cranberry chicken salad, now that’s a winner right there.
