Barstool Sports’ Dave Portnoy Gives Toms River Pizza Shop High Rating in Latest Review

In his latest one-bite review, Dave Portnoy of Barstool Sports gave PaciDough's Pizza Joint an impressive 8.2 out of 10. The cozy Toms River spot caught his eye with its remarkable pizzas.

Located in a strip mall on Atlantic City Boulevard past Water Street, PaciDough's catches everyone's attention with its 90s throwback atmosphere. Tony and Donielle Pacitti decorated their restaurant with vintage arcade games, old tapes, and wall art from the decade.

The menu features fun options like the Roni Soprano Pie and Super Mario Meatballs. After Portnoy's review hit online, orders started pouring in.

His New Jersey pizza journey included visits to De Lucia's in Raritan and Razza in Jersey City. The video showed their unique way of making naturally fermented dough.

While eating, Portnoy brought up the town's 1998 Little League World Series championship, making his visit more personal.

Now the small shop struggles to keep up with all the orders. Social media is full of locals showing off their hometown favorite.